Palestine, the mandated territory and the historical legal basis of Israel – a history that cannot simply be rewritten
Anyone who wants to discuss the creation of Israel, the so-called Mandatory Palestine and the allegedly illegal existence of the Jewish state should first take a look at history and, above all, at the international legal documents. Because history does not begin in 1948 or with the Six-Day War in 1967. And it certainly does not begin with a UN resolution.
It begins with the end of the Ottoman Empire and the reorganization of the Middle East after the First World War.
One fact is surprisingly often ignored: the original British mandate of Palestine initially also included the area east of the Jordan. Around 70 to 77 percent of the entire mandate area was later administratively separated and placed under Hashemite rule as Transjordan. The independent Kingdom of Jordan emerged from this area in 1946.
That was no small thing. It was the separation of by far the largest part of the original mandate area.
What was actually decided
The legal basis was the Balfour Declaration of November 2, 1917. In it, Great Britain declared its support for the establishment of a national home for the Jewish people in Palestine. The civil and religious rights of the non-Jewish population should be explicitly protected.
This declaration did not remain a non-binding political declaration of intent.
At the San Remo Conference in April 1920, the Allied victorious powers undertook the obligation to secure the establishment of a Jewish national home in Palestine under international law. The League of Nations confirmed this in 1922 with the Mandate for Palestine.
And this document is crucial.
In its preamble, the League of Nations explicitly recognized the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine and the reasons for re-establishing their national home in that land.
Article 2 obliged Great Britain to create the necessary political, administrative and economic conditions for the establishment of this national home.
Article 6 specifically called for facilitating Jewish immigration and encouraging the settlement of Jews in the countryside.
These were not Zionist wishes invented after the fact. They were provisions of an international legal instrument adopted by the League of Nations. gov.il +1
The 70 to 77 percent, which is surprisingly rarely talked about
Article 25 of the mandate authorized Great Britain to suspend the Jewish national homeland provisions east of the Jordan.
That’s exactly what happened in 1922.
Transjordan was organized as a separate administrative region and placed under Hashemite rule under Abdullah bin Hussein. In 1946 it became the independent Kingdom of Transjordan, which later took the name Jordan.
This meant that most of the original mandated territory had already been removed from the scope of the provisions on the Jewish national homeland.
The size: approximately 70 to 77 percent of the original mandate area.
One must remember this historical fact: the Jewish national homeland no longer had the entire original mandate area at its disposal. The eastern part had already been assigned to an Arab Hashemite monarchy.
And yet in today’s debates it is often acted as if the Jews had received a huge territory with Israel and taken everything from the Arabs.
The historical map tells a different story.
The Second Partition Plan and Arab Rejection
The next crucial milestone came in 1947.
On November 29, 1947, the United Nations passed Resolution 181. It recommended the division of the remaining mandated territory west of the Jordan into a Jewish and an Arab state. Jerusalem should be placed under a special international regime.
The Jewish leadership accepted the partition proposal, although with considerable reservations.
The Arab leadership and the Arab states rejected him.
This has to be recorded historically. The Arab side did not want to accept the proposed two-state solution. Instead, war and an attempt to militarily prevent the creation of a Jewish state followed.
Israel declared its independence on May 14, 1948.
However, Resolution 181 was a recommendation of the UN General Assembly and not a directly enforceable territorial title. Their rejection by the Arab side did not automatically transfer the entire proposed Arab territory to the Jewish side. This is an important legal distinction to be aware of when arguing international law.
The crucial Latin legal principle: Uti possidetis juris
And this brings us to a legal principle that is particularly interesting in this discussion:
Uti possidetis juris.
What it means is: What you legally own, you should continue to own.
The principle comes from international law and was particularly applied when new states were created. It is intended to prevent the previous legal administrative boundaries from being changed arbitrarily when a region becomes independent. The existing territorial borders essentially become the borders of the new state.
In relation to the end of the British mandate, this means: The territorial boundaries of the mandate area are of considerable importance for the international law consideration of the creation of a state.
However, one must remain legally clean: Uti possidetis juris does not mean that every square meter of the former mandated territory automatically belongs to a specific people. It is a principle of territorial succession, not ethnic title.
Article 80 of the UN Charter is also important in this context. It contains a grandfathering provision for the rights of states and peoples from existing international agreements as long as these have not been replaced by corresponding trust agreements.
The Israeli legal opinion sees this as an additional safeguard for the rights of the Jewish people recognized in the mandate. However, the scope of this provision is internationally controversial. un.org +1
Who owns Israel under international law?
Here you have to distinguish between three things that are often mixed together in political discussions:
- The historical law: The connection of the Jewish people with the Land of Israel is historically documented and was expressly recognized in the mandate of the League of Nations.
- The national right to self-determination: The Jewish people have the right to national self-determination. This right found its political realization in the founding of the State of Israel.
- The territorial borders: Israel’s current borders are not simply identical to the borders of the original mandated territory. The armistice lines of 1949, the borders after the Six-Day War and the later peace treaties have their own history under international law.
It would therefore not be legally tenable to claim that the entire former mandated territory today belongs unreservedly and exclusively to the State of Israel. Nor can it be claimed that the founding of Israel was contrary to international law or that the Jewish people there have no legitimate national rights.
The mandate of the League of Nations, the decisions of San Remo and the right to self-determination form an important international legal basis for the re-establishment of a Jewish national home and the emergence of Israel.
And this is precisely where the crucial difference lies between a historical fact and a political narrative.
The real historical irony
When people today talk about an allegedly unfair division of Palestine, one should perhaps first put the map from 1922 on the table.
A large part of the original mandated territory was already removed from the scope of the Jewish national homeland under British administration and assigned to Hashemite rule.
Then in 1947 another division was proposed.
The Jewish leadership accepted them. The Arab leadership rejected them.
And today Israel is being blamed for even existing.
This is a remarkable form of historical memory: you remember every border line that Israel supposedly got too much of, but you generously forget the entire history of the territorial division that has already taken place.
An honest debate would certainly be possible.
But what cannot be done seriously is to simply erase the history of the Jewish state under international law.
Israel is not a colonial gift from Britain. It is the political realization of the national right to self-determination of a people whose historical connection to this country existed before the emergence of modern international law and whose national homeland was expressly recognized by international resolutions.
And perhaps the next time we discuss Israel’s alleged illegality, we should ask ourselves a simple question:
If the Arab side had accepted partition in 1947, would there be two states west of the Jordan today?
Most likely.
The story has taken a different turn. But rejecting a political solution cannot retroactively erase Israel’s right to exist.
One can argue about Israel’s policies. Criticize his government. But one cannot pretend that the Jewish people only decided to invent a historical homeland in 1948.
Important primary sources and additional documents:
- San Remo Resolution of April 25, 1920.
- League of Nations Mandate for Palestine of July 24, 1922 – especially the preamble and articles 2, 6 and 25.
- Resolution on the administration of Transjordan from September 1922.
- UN report on the history of the mandated territory and the question of partition.
- Statement by the Israeli Attorney General on the principles of international law.